Share This Article
In any attempt to pick an insurance provider in America, State Farm and GEICO may sound familiar names on the market due to successful advertising campaigns. However, beyond advertising strategies, these two giants have radically different operational frameworks, insurance philosophy, and pricing models. State Farm holds a leading position among P&C insurers in terms of property insurance nationwide, providing a lion’s share of insurance for homes. As for GEICO, it is a subsidiary of the multinational financial conglomerate of Berkshire Hathaway. Its main competitive advantage in the automotive sector is its innovative online shopping experience.
The question of which insurer is ‘better’ depends on each person’s personal assets, their preferences in terms of technology use, as well as the type of insured assets – a vehicle, a house or even both. Comparing their operational framework, coverage advantages, and customer satisfaction level could reveal the best solution for an individual consumer’s situation.
1. Captive Local Agents vs. Direct-To-Consumer Model
Firstly, it is worth paying attention to the general structure of these two companies and the way they operate.
Local Agents of State Farm
State Farm heavily relies on its brick-and-mortar structure and its captive local agent corps. The company uses its network consisting of almost 19 thousand local agents in all states. ‘Captive’ refers to the fact that these individuals only sell insurance products offered by State Farm. Thus, in case you value human communication and personalized approach, prefer to meet and talk with someone face-to-face, discuss all the terms of the contract or get a local professional to check a property renovation for potential insurance problems, State Farm is definitely the best solution here.
Direct-To-Consumer Model of GEICO
As for GEICO, the company mainly focuses on its digital online and mobile platforms. The number of GEICO offices in different cities of America is extremely limited, as the corporation provides its services in the form of a direct-to-consumer platform. Due to its minimalistic office presence, GEICO has no need to incur additional expenses, which enables it to set a competitive baseline price for its clients.
2. Auto Insurance Comparison
Secondly, GEICO and State Farm provide excellent coverage plans for automotive insurance, but they target different types of drivers and offer slightly varied technological solutions for rewarding their clients for safe driving experience.
Baseline Premium Prices: On a macro scale in the USA, GEICO tends to have the cheapest rates for those who are experienced and do not have any traffic violations or claims history. Still, State Farm can undercut these rates when speaking about some high-risk groups such as families that would like to add a teen driver to the family plan.
Telematic Applications for Safe Driving
Both GEICO and State Farm offer telematic applications to track the way drivers use their cars. These applications calculate the speed, frequency of braking, or distractions and apply discounts for good driving experience. The discount program of State Farm is called Drive Safe and Save, while GEICO calls theirs DriveEasy. The main difference is that DriveEasy is able to decrease the price based on the quality of driving experience, while the latter may increase rates if drivers behave aggressively.
3. Property Insurance
If you are a home or property owner, your insurance needs become drastically different and the comparison of these carriers changes accordingly.
Home Insurance of State Farm
State Farm is a giant in the sphere of property insurance, as it underwrites all home policies independently from any third parties. Since State Farm has complete authority over your coverage, its local agents can help you to evaluate the cost of property repair, risks connected to local weather conditions and even customize your riders in case you want to insure any high-value belongings.
Insurance Agency of GEICO
GEICO cannot sell any property insurance policies, as the company acts merely as an agent, selling policies issued by several third-party insurers including Travelers, Homesite, and Liberty Mutual. Although GEICO allows you to see your insurance information in their online portal and gives you an additional multi-policy bundling discount in case you purchase auto and home insurance at the same time, the claims process in case of damage to your home will involve dealing with a third-party insurer.
4. Financial Strength Rating
Finally, when it comes to making the decision, the consumers should pay attention to the independent ratings issued by A.M. Best and J.D. Power.
Financial Stability: A.M. Best Company has assigned both insurance providers the maximum A++ rating, meaning that both companies have enough liquidity and reserves to cover all the claims, even if they happen to occur after a widespread disaster of natural origin.
Customer Satisfaction: According to J.D. Power surveys, State Farm consistently ranks a bit above the industry average in terms of claims handling. The advantage of this insurance company in comparison to others is the ability to consult their policyholders in person when dealing with complicated situations involving structural damages. In its turn, GEICO’s customer satisfaction is slightly lower or equal to the industry standard, as their online claims process works extremely fast in the case of small automobile accidents, but not always.
Final Thoughts
Thus, we may conclude that neither of these carriers is generally better than another one, and they both focus on different consumer preferences.
Generally, if a person likes online interfaces and prefers to save as much money on insurance as possible, the best choice for them would be GEICO – they have some of the lowest premiums in the country. Otherwise, if a person wants comprehensive coverage and the personalized approach from their insurance agents, State Farm should be considered. In order to find out the best insurance rates in your specific situation, please contact both companies online and provide them with identical coverage terms.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Does GEICO provide a bigger discount on bundled multi-policy premiums?
A: Both companies offer generous multi-policy discounts ranging from 15% to 25%. However, since State Farm provides all types of insurance policies themselves, their bundling process goes faster. Even though you still have to pay a lower price if you buy auto and property insurance together from GEICO, your property insurance will be underwritten by one of their partners.
Q: Do these insurance providers offer different services for roadside assistance?
A: Both GEICO and State Farm provide optional roadside assistance packages including flat tire changes, towing and lockout services. One of the advantages of GEICO’s option is the integration with its mobile application, allowing policyholders to track the location of the tow truck in real-time. In contrast, State Farm offers emergency road service, requiring customers to call an agent to dispatch a truck.
Q: Which company is better in terms of mechanical breakdown insurance?
A: GEICO stands out with its Mechanical Breakdown Insurance program that provides extra coverage for the car’s engine, transmission and electrical components. This optional add-on covers new cars up to 12 years old and under certain mileage. State Farm does not offer MBI but has comprehensive insurance plans to cover all kinds of losses related to your automobile.
Q: Will I lose my policy after moving to another state?
A: Moving to another state does not make a person cancel the existing policy but to update it according to the latest address. In case of State Farm, it usually means transferring your account to another agent located at your new place of residence. If you move within the territory of coverage offered by GEICO, you should simply log into your mobile application and fill in your new address.